Comparison between Thayers Blemish Clearing Pads vs. La Roche-Posay Effaclar Clarifying Solution Acne Toner With Salicylic Acid

Find out which product is better for your skin.

15 Ingredients 18

1
Water
1
.05%
2
Certified Organic Witch Hazel Extract Blend
2
Salicylic Acid
3
Hamamelis Virginiana (Witch Hazel) Bark/​leaf/​twig Extract
3
Water
4
Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract (Filet Of Aloe Vera)
4
Alcohol Denatured
5
Hamamelis Virginiana (Witch Hazel) Bark/​leaf/​twig Extract
5
Propanediol
6
Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract (Filet Of Aloe Vera)
6
Glycolic Acid
7
Melaleuca Alternifolia (Tea Tree) Leaf Oil
7
Sodium Hydroxide
8
Cymbopogon Flexuosus Oil
8
Capryloyl Glycine
-- Show others --
Uniqueness13 out of 15
86.7%
Uniqueness16 out of 18
88.9%

Positive Effects

Find out what good effects the product has

ECO Metrics

Find out how eco-friendly the components are
Vegan
No
No
Cruelty free
No
No
Reef friendly
Yes
Yes
Ozone layer safe
Yes
Yes
Organic score
natural
6 out of 15
40%
chemical
3 out of 15
20%
natural
4 out of 18
22%
chemical
10 out of 18
56%

Concerns

Pay attention to these components
-- Extra information --

Components by Skin Type

Find out what components are good or bad for your skin type
Dry skin
Positive: 1Negative: 0
Glycerin#9
Oily skin
Positive: 0Negative: 0
Sensitive skin
Positive: 0Negative: 2
Melaleuca Alternifolia (Tea Tree) Leaf Oil#7Citric Acid#12
Dry skin
Positive: 1Negative: 1
Butylene Glycol#16Alcohol Denatured#4
Oily skin
Positive: 3Negative: 0
Salicylic Acid#2Glycolic Acid#6Menthol#13
Sensitive skin
Positive: 0Negative: 3
Salicylic Acid#2Glycolic Acid#6Menthol#13

Detailed view

Thayers Blemish Clearing Pads vs. La Roche-Posay Effaclar Clarifying Solution Acne Toner With Salicylic Acid
Position 1

#1Water

Origin: natural
Role: Solvent
EWG Rating [ 1 ]

Water is a great solvent. It’s neutral and doesn’t provide any strong positive or negative effects. It just helps components to mix better and to transport active components.

-- versus --

#1.05%

Origin: No information
Role: No information
Position 2

#2Certified Organic Witch Hazel Extract Blend

Origin: natural
Role: No information
-- versus --

#2Salicylic Acid

Origin: chemical
Role: Skin conditioning agent, Antiacne agent, Antidandruff agent, Exfoliant, Fragrance ingredient, Hair conditioning, Keratolytic, Masking, Preservative
Cleansing
Acne fighting
Soothing
Antiseptic
EWG Rating [ 1 ]
CIR Rating [ B ]
Good for oily skin
Good for oily skin

Salicylic Acid is an amazing component for oily skin. It’s a famous BHA that chemically exfoliates dead cells, kills bacteria, and prevents acne. It works as a strong pores cleanser. AHAs are not effective for removing sebum from pores, while BHAs are leaders in this space. Salicylic Acid also helps to shrink pores, remove acne scars and make skin tone even. Pay attention: concentration matters! This ingredient is rather aggressive. It can lead to irritation in high concentrations. If your skin has never seen this component before test the product first.

Position 3

#3Hamamelis Virginiana (Witch Hazel) Bark/​leaf/​twig Extract

Origin: No information
Role: No information
-- versus --

#3Water

Origin: natural
Role: Solvent
EWG Rating [ 1 ]

Water is a great solvent. It’s neutral and doesn’t provide any strong positive or negative effects. It just helps components to mix better and to transport active components.

Position 4

#4Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract (Filet Of Aloe Vera)

Origin: No information
Role: No information
-- versus --

#4Alcohol Denatured

Origin: chemical
Role: Antifoaming agent, Antimicrobial agent, Astringent, Masking, Solvent, Viscosity controlling agent
Antiseptic
Alcohols
EWG Rating [ 1 ]
Bad for dry skin
Bad for dry skin

Alcohol Denatured is a great bacteria killer. Manufacturers often put it inside products to increase their shelf life.

It’s one of the most harmful alcohols used in skincare. You should use it carefully, especially if you have dry skin. It removes oily barrier from the surface of your skin making it less protected and causing dryness. We advise you to pay attention to the position of this component in a formulation. If it stays below the 6th position it will hardly harm your skin. We also recommend testing the product first before application. If you feel a “cooling effect” it means the product contains a lot of alcohol and it's better to be careful with it.

Position 5

#5Hamamelis Virginiana (Witch Hazel) Bark/​leaf/​twig Extract

Origin: No information
Role: No information
-- versus --

#5Propanediol

Origin: chemical
Role: Solvent, Viscosity controlling agent
Moisturizing
Hair conditioning
EWG Rating [ 2 ]

Propanediol is a good solvent, emollient and humectant. It helps to moisturize the skin and prevent moisture loss. In haircare products, it conditions hair and improves absorption of the product.

Skin Signal
2023 - 2024

The most advanced ingredient checker and cosmetics analyzer. Take a look "inside" the skincare products you use every day.

Disclaimer: All the information on the website is not a medical advice. Visit a doctor if you have problems.

Privacy policy Terms of Service